Two Video Games With Identical Names Went Way Beyond Managing To Coexist

Posted

In the video game industry, trademark disputes over similarly named games are not remotely uncommon. Usually when this happens, we’re talking about one same or similar word amongst games names: “scroll”, or “rage”, or “wasteland”. Those tend to annoy us, because they seem certain to fail the real test of trademark law in most cases, which is whether or not the buying public will be confused about an association or similar source between the products.

But what if there were two games named identically that were released in close proximity to each other? We saw that exact thing happen earlier this year, when two unrelated games that shared the title Piece by Piece were released on Steam.

Earlier this year, Piece by Piece launched on Steam. Then another game, also called Piece by Piece, launched on Steam.

“Back when we announced the Steam launch date for our Piece by Piece in March, a day later the Piece by Piece from Neon Polygons also announced their launch date, and it was two days after ours,” said Mike Rose, co-founder of No More Robots. He said he got a nervous email from Neon Polygons, concerned that No More Robots would go after them for having a game of the same name.

This sort of thing happens all the time, of course. Two companies or developers working separately on projects that have similar, or identical in this case, titles for their work by pure happenstance. There’s nothing malicious here. There’s no intent to confuse anyone, or to ride off of someone’s coattails.

But because this is business and the only way to really protect your investment is to participate in the IP-maxing of your product… right?

As it turns out, no, you can just be human and awesome instead.

“I got back to them and said ‘Well, that’s just hilarious. Do you wanna bundle up on Steam? I did it partially because it was a nice / fun thing to do, but I also kinda did it because I love chaos.”

It’s a beautiful story about how not being an asshole can lead to other joint business opportunities, so long as you don’t default to IP protectionism. The games are different, nobody is confused, but why not bundle them together.

It’s a great little tale if that’s as far as it went. But it gets funnier when they decided to keep teaming up for a release on Nintendo’s Switch.

Now they’re launching together on the Switch under the same publishing label, because sometimes video games and the people who make them are good.

“We had to explain over and over again, to each separate Nintendo organization (Europe, Japan, America), that ‘No, sorry but those are two separate games. Yes, they have the same name. Yes, they have the same release date. Yes, we are very sorry. We promise we won’t do this again,’” Rose said.

It apparently took repeated conversations to explain to Nintendo why the two companies were working together instead of slugging it out either in court or with the USPTO over trademark concerns. It’s quite fun for me to picture Nintendo execs and lawyers sitting around a conference room phone, being told by these two developers that they’re not going to war over the shared titles, as they sit their with confused looks because that just doesn’t compute to Nintendo.

More of this please. More people choosing humanity over IP maximalism. It’ll make the world a better, more fun place, I promise you.

1, neon polygons, nintendo, no more robots, not assholes, piece by piece, trademark, video games